Business Growth

When Good KPIs Drive Bad Outcomes

Metrics scale easily. Context does not. Why the KPIs executives trust most are the ones most likely to mislead them.

By Bill Ryan · 2026-11-17

When Good KPIs Drive Bad Outcomes

Metrics scale easily. Context doesn’t.

If the CRO needs $7 million in new revenue and the average deal size is $250,000, the team needs 28 deals. At a 25% win rate, that means 112 qualified opportunities. If 40% of first meetings become qualified opportunities, it needs 280 meetings. You work backward until you get to activities people can control. Then you build targets, assign ownership and manage against them. That is a reasonable way to run a sales organization.

But those targets depend on assumptions. The meetings have to be with the right people. Opportunities have to be qualified consistently. The average deal size and win rate have to hold. It is easy to lose sight of those assumptions once everyone has a number to hit.

More Meetings, Less Business

Say the team is behind on first meetings. The CRO pushes the managers, the managers push the reps, and everyone gets focused on booking more meetings. SDRs start booking conversations they would have passed on a month ago. Marketing broadens the audience. Reps agree to meet with prospects who have some interest but no real reason to buy.

Thirty days later, meetings are up 30%. That looks like progress until you see that meeting-to-opportunity conversion has fallen by half. The team is having more conversations and creating fewer qualified opportunities.

Now the salespeople are busier, but they are spending more time with prospects who are unlikely to buy. Some of those conversations make it into pipeline anyway, because there is pressure to build pipeline too. Managers spend more time inspecting deals that should never have been there, and the forecast gets harder to trust. Nobody had to do anything dishonest for this to happen. People responded to the priorities leadership gave them.

Are the KPIs Still Working?

Meetings, pipeline, POCs, partners and new logos can all be useful KPIs. But we have to look at what they produce.

A company with 25 pilots underway might have real traction. But if customers keep testing and never adopt, launching more pilots will not solve the problem. That is how useful KPIs become vanity metrics. We start celebrating the activity without checking the results.

There is a name for this: Campbell’s Law. The harder you push people to hit a number, the more likely they are to change their behavior to hit it, even if that defeats the original purpose.

The Context Gets Lost

This gets harder as companies grow. In a smaller organization, the people doing the work are often close enough to understand why a target exists. They hear the customer conversations. They know which deals went sideways and why. They may have been in the room when the team decided what to focus on. Add a few management layers, hire more people and split the work across functions, and that shared understanding gets harder to maintain.

The CRO might say, “We need more qualified pipeline from these enterprise accounts because the current mix will not support the revenue plan.” By the time that gets to the rep, the instruction is, “Book ten more meetings this month.” The rep can hit that target without solving the problem the CRO was trying to address.

They might book smaller accounts, meet with people who cannot influence a purchase or pull conversations forward before there is a real opportunity. From the rep’s perspective, those may be reasonable choices. They were given a meeting target, and they are trying to hit it.

We cannot expect everyone to carry the entire company strategy in their head. But they need to understand the assumptions behind their targets. Without that context, people have to fill in the gaps themselves. And if their performance review or compensation depends on a number, that number is going to carry a lot of weight.

Look One Step Downstream

When we work with a sales organization, we don’t stop at whether meetings or pipeline are up. We look at what those meetings and that pipeline are producing. For meetings, that means qualified opportunities. For pipeline, it means stage conversion, win rates and sales cycles. For POCs, it means customers moving into production. For partners, it means actual contribution to the business.

New logos need the same scrutiny. Adding customers looks good, but if those customers buy small, require a lot of support and leave at renewal, we may be building a more expensive business rather than a better one.

Start by looking one step downstream from the KPIs you are pushing hardest. If the activity is increasing but the next result is getting worse, find out why. The people doing the work will often see the problem before it shows up in the numbers. Ask the reps whether these are conversations they think will turn into business.

What Leadership Owns

If we give people a target, we owe them an explanation of how we got there and what we expect it to accomplish. If we ask for more meetings, the team needs to know why we believe those meetings will create more business: which accounts we are targeting, who we need to meet with and what makes a qualified opportunity.

That understanding helps people keep the end goal in sight and flag when the activity is unlikely to produce the result we expect. A rep should be able to say, “I can book these meetings, but I don’t think they will create the pipeline we need.” Leadership has to give people enough context to recognize that problem and make it clear we expect them to raise it. Managers need to reinforce that in team meetings, deal reviews and coaching, then listen when someone challenges an assumption.

Sometimes a green dashboard means the business is working. Sometimes it means the organization has simply gotten very good at hitting the dashboard.

The job of leadership is not to make the dashboard green. It is to make sure the dashboard still tells the truth.


Bill Ryan is a Co-Founder & Managing Partner at Big Wheel Performance. He helps enterprise sales and SaaS companies build capital-efficient growth by aligning sales, marketing, and customer success into flywheels that scale beyond founder dependence.